Mediation vs. Arbitration – What is the Difference?

Mediation and Arbitration are making the headlines more and more these days. Many times it’s regarding a professional sports team, a union or another group that is in dispute and requires assistance in coming to a resolution. I also regularly receive calls from families who are separating or divorcing and are unsure about what these Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) processes can offer. Hopefully, I can shed some light on this.

Both in arbitration and mediation, people choose the arbitrator or mediator so they can ensure this person has a background and understanding that is suitable for their dispute. These processes are private, less formal and take place more quickly than court. In each case, parties can usually have access to the mediator or arbitrator if needed. A mediation or arbitration clause can be included in an agreement or contract in the case of a future dispute. However, there are also some very distinct differences between mediation and arbitration as well.

In mediation, a mediator is impartial or treats all parties equally and fairly. They can guide and assist people who are in a dispute to communicate clearly, to be heard by one another and to help them resolve their differences. The discussions in mediation are confidential and the goal is for everyone to have their needs met. The mediator doesn’t take sides or make any decisions for the people involved – the parties retain control of the outcome. The agreement reached in mediation is written up by the mediator and this agreement can be legalized through the courts or a lawyer if the parties agree. It is recommended that that people participating in mediation get legal advice so that they know their rights and responsibilities.

In arbitration, an arbitrator is a neutral third party who listens to both sides of a dispute. They then make decisions for the parties based on evidence and law. Decisions made are often legally binding and the outcome can be enforced like a court order. This process can be considered to be a “private court” and there are no public filings or hearings made. Many times people who attend arbitration do so because of the terms of a contract. Arbitration is governed by laws and arbitrators do not have jurisdiction in the areas of divorce, custody, child support, criminal and will and estates.

Mediation and arbitration have some similarities and differences. What makes them stand apart is who makes the decisions and how their agreements are made legal. In mediation, the parties make decisions based open and honest discussions. Agreements reached in mediation can be used as the basis of a legal agreement or court order. In arbitration, a neutral third party or arbitrator makes decisions based on evidence and law and these decisions are usually binding. Deciding which process to use really depends on each individual situation and whether there is a previous contact or agreement in place which states how disputes are to be resolved.

If you would like more information, feel free to contact me or book your 20 minute no-charge phone consultation online at http://www.garneaumediation.ca/book-a-consultation/.

Michelle Garneau
Registered Family Mediator
Garneau Mediation Services
780-417-3119 (office) 780-499-9815 (cell)
michelle@garneaumediation.ca
www.garneaumediation.ca

Comments are closed.